You are listening to the Less Drama More Mama podcast, episode 350: The Myth of “I Turned Out Fine” That Keeps Generational Cycles Going
This is Less Drama More Mama, the podcast for moms who want to feel calm, in control, and confident about how to handle anything life throws their way. If you’re ready to go from feeling frazzled and disrespected to feeling calm and connected, this is the podcast for you. I’m your host, Pam Howard.
Hi Mama! Welcome to the show! Before we dive into today’s topic, I want to take a moment to celebrate that this is episode 350! Over six and a half years of podcasting has created a wealth of resources for you, and I want to make sure you know how to access them. I created a podcast directory that can help you navigate through the first 300 episodes and easily find topics you’re dealing with. Whether you want tips on managing your own emotions, strategies for feeling more confident in your parenting, or ways to help your kids with specific issues, this directory has got you covered. It’s available for free in today’s show notes at lessdramamoremama.com/350. From there, you can download it as a PDF and keep it handy whenever you need a little inspiration or guidance.
To help me celebrate this milestone, I’d love for you to leave an honest review of the podcast on your favorite platform. It’s a simple and powerful way to show your support, and it helps other moms like you discover the show and join our growing community. I’ll even give you a shout-out in a future episode. Thank you so much in advance.
Now, let’s get into today’s topic. What does it really mean when someone says ‘I was spanked and I turned out fine?’ Today I’m unpacking this common justification that keeps generational patterns of physical discipline going. A few weeks ago, I had a conversation I can’t get out of my mind. I met a man in his early 80s who asked what I do for a living. When I told him I help moms feel more calm and confident in their parenting, he looked right at me and asked, “What do you think about hitting?” I told him, simply and clearly, “I don’t believe in it.” His response was, “I think your way is wrong.” Now, that’s ok. I’d had conversations like this before with people of the same generation. I stayed curious, and we kept talking.
He told me about how his father used to whip him. And when I asked him to give me an example of something that warranted such a punishment, he said he accidentally made a loud noise that disrupted his dad’s concentration. That was it. He was basically punished for being a kid. The thing is, he talked about it with pride and eventually said the most common justification I hear for physical discipline, “I turned out fine.” But what does “fine” actually mean? Does it mean you survived? That you learned to stay quiet and keep the peace? Does it mean you became successful in your career, but feel anxious or disconnected in personal relationships? Does it mean you can’t set boundaries without guilt? Or that you struggle to feel safe showing emotion? Does it mean you’re respected but not truly known by others? Saying “I turned out fine” doesn’t tell me that the punishment worked. It tells me you adapted. You coped. You learned how to function within a certain system, and maybe that system taught you that love had to be earned, or that mistakes meant you were bad. Does hitting work? Sure, fear gets compliance in the short-term, but it doesn’t build trust in a relationship. It doesn’t teach why something is wrong or how to make a better choice the next time. And it certainly doesn’t model self-regulation or emotional safety.
Even when people say, “I was spanked, and I turned out fine,” research shows that many children who are spanked are not fine. The evidence consistently shows negative outcomes, while not a single study shows that physical punishment is associated with anything positive for children. When someone says ‘I turned out fine,’ they’re sharing their personal experience, which is valid, but they can’t know how they might have turned out with different disciplinary approaches. And they can’t see the internal struggles they may have normalized, like difficulty managing emotions or forming secure relationships.
In 2016, Drs. Gershoff and Grogan-Kaylor analyzed data from over 160,000 children and found that spanking was linked to increased aggression, mental health problems, and antisocial behavior. The research also found that adults who were spanked were more likely to support physical punishment for their own children, continuing the cycle. This is why the work we do in Damn Good Mama is so important. We’re not just changing our own parenting; we’re breaking generational patterns. We’re giving our children a different experience than the one we had, and in doing so, changing how they’ll parent their own children some day. Many of our parents used physical discipline because it was what they knew, what their communities expected, and what they believed would help us succeed in life. They were doing their best with the tools they had. But now we know more. We understand how children’s brains develop, how discipline affects the parent-child relationship, and what approaches actually help children internalize the values we hope to teach them.
When people say, “kids nowadays are entitled and need to be spanked,” I hear a legitimate concern about raising responsible children who understand boundaries and consequences. It’s a goal I completely share! The difference is that now we understand there are more effective ways to reach it.
The research shows that children who aren’t spanked but are disciplined with clear boundaries, natural consequences, and respectful guidance actually develop better self-regulation and more internal motivation to do the right thing. They’re less likely to act entitled because they’ve learned to make good choices on their own, not just when someone bigger is threatening punishment.
My 80-year-old friend might say his generation turned out better because they were whipped, but when we look at measures of empathy, emotional regulation, and handling conflict without aggression – all skills needed to be successful in today’s world – children raised without physical punishment actually show stronger outcomes. What looks like entitlement to some is often children learning to express their needs and feelings – something we want them to do. The key is teaching them appropriate ways to do this while still respecting others. That’s what positive discipline accomplishes. When we know better, we can do better, not because our parents were wrong or bad, but because we now have access to information and approaches they didn’t have.
Now, I know what some of you might be thinking: “This all sounds great, Pam, but what about when my partner says, “I was spanked and I turned out fine” and we end up arguing about discipline approaches?” This is one of the most common challenges parents face. When you’re trying to break generational patterns but your co-parent isn’t on the same page, it can feel impossible to move forward. Here’s what I’ve learned works best: start by focusing on what you can control – your own reactions and responses. When we try to change someone else before we’ve changed ourselves, we often hit resistance. But when they see you modeling a different approach and getting positive results, that can be more persuasive than any argument. Instead of trying to win the debate about harsh discipline, demonstrate the alternative. Show your partner what regulated responses look like. Share the small wins when your calmer approach works. And remember that your child benefits enormously from having even one parent who’s committed to breaking the cycle. With many of the moms I work with, their skeptical partners gradually come around after seeing the results – not because they were convinced by research or arguments, but because they witnessed the positive changes in the relationship between their spouse and their kids. Change begins with you, and oftentimes, that’s enough to shift the entire family dynamic.
Now that we’ve seen what science tells us about physical discipline, let’s talk about what effective discipline actually looks like in practice. Effective discipline includes things like natural consequences. If your child refuses to wear a coat, they experience being cold. Logical consequences: If they misuse a toy, they lose the privilege of playing with it for a while. Problem-solving together by asking questions like, “How can you make sure this doesn’t happen again?” And “What would help you remember?” And repair work: If they break something, they help fix it or do extra chores to earn money toward replacing it. These consequences teach rather than just hurt. They help children understand the impact of their choices and develop better decision-making skills. For a toddler having a meltdown at the grocery store: Instead of, “Stop crying right now or you’re getting a spanking when we get to the car!” you can get down on their level and say, “I understand you’re upset. Let’s take a deep breath together. We need to finish the shopping, and then we can leave.” For a teen who missed curfew: Instead of, “That’s it! I’ve had it with your disrespect – you’re grounded for a month!” you can say, “I was worried when you didn’t come home on time. We need to talk about what happened and figure out how to rebuild trust. Let’s discuss this tomorrow when we’re both calm and rested.” Then follow through the next day. I know this approach can feel soft if you were raised with strict discipline. You might worry your kids are getting off easy compared to what you experienced. I get it. When I first started parenting this way, I sometimes felt like I wasn’t being tough enough. But I’ve learned that this approach is actually harder. It takes more thought, more self-control, and more consistency than reacting with punishment. It requires us to put in the work of teaching and being intentional rather than just reacting. Hitting a child or taking away something they love are the easier, quicker options in the moment. They’re a shortcut, but they don’t teach the lessons we really want our children to learn. Being thoughtful about discipline—setting clear boundaries with meaningful, relevant consequences—is the challenging work of parenting. Instead of teaching our kids to fear us, this approach teaches them to make good choices even when we’re not looking. That’s not soft. That’s smart parenting.
I’ve shared before about my own turning point in parenting—that time I spanked Marissa and immediately knew I needed to change. I won’t go into all the details again here, but I want to remind you that this topic is personal for me, too. I understand the urge to spank because I’ve felt it. I’ve acted on it. And I’ve had to face the reality that it didn’t accomplish what I wanted. The relationships I’ve since built with my teenage daughters is the result of choosing connection over control, of learning to regulate my own emotions first, and of committing to breaking a generational pattern even when it was uncomfortable. The trust and open communication we share today didn’t happen by accident. It happened because I was willing to do the harder work of teaching rather than punishing.
Something most people don’t talk about is that when you try to change your style of parenting, things often get worse before they get better. When a child is used to you reacting harshly, and you start responding with calm, respectful boundaries, surprisingly it doesn’t always go smoothly. Kids don’t usually change their behavior right away. In fact, they often escalate first because they’re testing to see if they can trust the new version of you.
Over the weekend I was talking to my friend. He and his wife fostered a teenage boy who had lived through years of instability and emotional neglect. During the time the boy was with them, he was guarded, shut down, and sometimes defiant. They wondered if anything they were doing was making a difference in his life. Eventually, the boy left to live abroad with his biological father—someone he hadn’t seen in years. He was gone for about a year and then one day he called my friend and asked if he could come back to stay with him again. When he returned, he was more talkative and more open than before. He was laughing with them, initiating conversation, letting his walls down. He felt safe with them, but it didn’t happen overnight. The seeds they had planted the previous year needed time to grow.
When I worked at an adolescent day treatment center in Boston, I saw the same sort of thing. We saw kids diagnosed with every disorder in the book. None of them were able to manage a typical school environment and many were completely shut down emotionally. Every day, my coworkers and I showed up with kindness, respect, and healthy boundaries. And at first, many of them pushed back and acted out. But over time, because we were consistent in our approach, most softened, and their behavior changed to the point where they were able to return to a school setting successfully.
So if you’ve been trying to parent differently and your child’s behavior has gotten worse since you stopped yelling or spanking, that doesn’t mean you’re doing it wrong. It means your child is learning to navigate a completely different dynamic where the goal is connection rather than control. It does get easier, but if you find yourself stuck in guilt, reactivity, or second-guessing, I’d love to help. Book a 15-minute call with me at lessdramamoremama.com/chat to learn if my group program, Damn Good Mama, is right for you.
Let me share some recent wins from the moms in Damn Good Mama. One mom used to get irritated when her daughter blew up her phone with text messages. Recently, instead of reacting, she paused, and realized her daughter wasn’t being rude—she just didn’t know better. So she taught her what respectful communication looks like over text. The result was less tension and a daughter who now understands digital boundaries. This mom shared that she feels proud of herself for teaching rather than just reacting, and their relationship feels more respectful in both directions. Another mom kept her cool during a chaotic morning of sibling drama in the car. She didn’t yell. She didn’t spiral out of control like she used to. Instead, she stayed neutral, set a boundary with a simple consequence, and moved on. Her kids accepted it without pushback. She’s finally trusting herself to parent effectively without losing control. Another mom followed through with screen-time limits and saw her son’s grades improve. And another mom shared that her daughter woke up in tears after realizing she hadn’t finished making bracelets for her softball team. Instead of saying, “Well, I told you to do them earlier,” she met her daughter with empathy and space to feel her emotions. Once the daughter settled down, they came up with a plan together and her daughter finished all the bracelets that night. Those are the kinds of shifts that happen in Damn Good Mama: less reactivity, more trust, and kids who rise to the occasion when they feel supported, not shamed.
That conversation with the 80-year-old man has stayed with me because it represents the heart of breaking generational patterns. When someone says “I turned out fine,” they’re often protecting themselves from acknowledging unnecessary pain. They’re preserving the narrative that harsh discipline was somehow necessary or beneficial. I don’t want my children to just turn out fine. I want them to thrive—to feel secure, understood, and capable of deep connection. That’s why I choose to parent differently than how I was parented, and it’s why I’m passionate about helping you do the same. Breaking these cycles isn’t easy. It requires us to question what we’ve normalized, to focus on ourselves, and to choose the harder path of teaching rather than controlling. But with each conscious choice, we’re not just raising healthier children, we’re healing ourselves, too. If you’re ready to move beyond ‘fine’ in your parenting journey, I’m here to support you. Have a great week and I’ll talk to you again next time. Bye.
If you enjoy listening to this podcast, and you’re ready to feel calmer, more confident and more at peace in your family and life, I invite you to sign up for a free consultation with me to learn about how my coaching can help you achieve the exact life you want. You’ll take the concepts and tools I share in the podcast and apply them to your own life, and as your coach I’ll be there to support you every step of the way. Go to lessdramamoremama.com/mini and sign up now.